Prequel Trilogy,  Revenge of the Sith

Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith: a fight between Obi-Wan and 6 MagnaGuards was almost filmed


From Entertainment Weekly:

“The best lightsaber fight in the Star Wars franchise may be one that you never saw.

That’s the opinion of stunt coordinator Nick Gillard, who helped choreograph the fights throughout the prequel trilogy.

Gillard was discussing the lightsaber battle in The Phantom Menance when we mentioned that the Darth Maul vs. Obi-Wan and Qui-Gon three-way bout is considered by many fans to be the best laser sword contest in the entire saga.

Then Gillard surprised us by revealing: No… there is another…

There is “a better one” fans never saw, Gillard said — a Revenge of the Sith fight in which Obi-Wan takes on six of General Grievous’ bodyguards at the same time.

Star Ewan McGregor trained for weeks just to get Obi-Wan’s choreography down for the complicated sequence. But when it came time to film, the production was running short on time. Since the fight wasn’t essential to the story line, George Lucas invented a simpler to eliminate the bodyguards: Obi-Wan uses the Force to crush them with a piece of the ceiling.

“It was the most complicated fight we ever did, and George said, ‘I’m really sorry, I’m going to drop a container on five of them!’”

Here’s the end result:”


  • Arnav “RayO1” Bhattacharjee

    Not almost filmed, it was filmed, but they just cut it. And honestly? This sounds like a terrible decision on George’s part. Not holding it against him or anything, but having spoken with prequel haters, a complaint one of them brought up was that it was unrealistic for Obi-Wan to be able to fight Grievous in such a manner without any prior setup. The fight with the MagnaGuards would have been that proper setup, so the prequel haters would have one less thing to whine about. Yeah, now we have TCW to fill in those gaps, but in the eyes of the masses that hadn’t seen TCW…well, they were probably a bit confused is all. I wasn’t, but they were, so their concern mattered.

Leave a Reply to Arnav “RayO1” Bhattacharjee Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.